What Is a Letter of Spoliation?

A letter of spoliation tells defendants that they need to save pieces of evidence from alteration or destruction. Sending these letters is routine for our Phoenix personal injury lawyers, but they are essential to tort cases.

If the defendant violates the letter and tampers with the evidence, your lawyer can inform the court, and they can take appropriate action for spoliation of evidence. This could make it much easier for you to win your case. Here’s what you need to know about these letters.

Why Are These Letters Sent?

A letter of spoliation is a formal notice sent to defendants instructing them to preserve specific evidence related to your case. This evidence could be physical objects, documents, or electronic data. The purpose is to prevent any alteration, destruction, or loss of crucial information that could impact your claim.

For example, if you had a slip-and-fall accident in a store, a letter of spoliation may demand that the store preserve any camera footage that caught the incident. They cannot lose, delete, or tamper with it.

If a trial happens and the evidence has been spoiled, your lawyer can tell the judge they sent notice to preserve it. This creates a situation called spoliation of evidence, and the court may punish the defendant.

For a free legal consultation, call 866-499-8989

What Are Some Consequences of Spoliation of Evidence?

Courts rely on evidence to reach just decisions. When evidence is tampered with or destroyed, it undermines the entire legal process. As a result, judges have several options to punish parties who engage in spoliation:

• Case Dismissal: If a plaintiff spoils evidence, their entire case could be thrown out.
• Default Judgment: If a defendant is responsible for spoliation, the court might rule in favor of the plaintiff without a trial.
• Financial Sanctions: The court may impose monetary penalties on the offending party.
• Adverse Inference: The judge might instruct the jury to assume the destroyed evidence would have been unfavorable to the party that spoiled it. This is known as a spoliation instruction.
• Extended Discovery: The court may allow additional time for the harmed party to gather new evidence to replace what was lost.

What Kinds of Evidence Can Spoliation Letters Ask to Preserve?

A letter of spoliation can ask for anything relevant to the case to be preserved. Your lawyer probably has a standard list of evidence to ask for in different kinds of cases. For example, truck accident evidence can include:

• Vehicles involved in an accident
• Phone records (in cases of distracted driving)
• Insurance information
• Medical records
• Surveillance footage
• Repair estimates
• Witness statements
• Emails or text messages related to the incident
• Maintenance logs
• Employee training records

Click to contact our personal injury lawyers today

Do You Need to Send a Spoliation Letter if You’re Not Planning to Sue?

Even if you’re not currently planning to file a lawsuit, sending a spoliation letter can be a wise precaution. Here’s why:

• It keeps your options open if negotiations break down.
• It ensures evidence is preserved in case you change your mind about litigation.
• It can strengthen your position during settlement talks.

Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now

The Role of Spoliation Letters in Settlement Negotiations

Spoliation letters play a crucial role not just in litigation but also in settlement negotiations. These letters can significantly influence the dynamics of pre-trial discussions and potentially lead to more favorable outcomes for you.

By sending a spoliation letter, you demonstrate to the opposing party that you’re serious about your claim and prepared to protect your legal rights. This can:

• Encourage the defendant to take your case more seriously
• Potentially lead to higher settlement offers
• Show that you have legal representation looking out for your interests

With all relevant evidence preserved, both parties can make more informed decisions about settlement. This can lead to:

• More productive negotiation sessions
• Faster resolution of claims
• Fair settlements that truly reflect the merits of the case

What to Do if You Receive a Spoliation Letter

If you’ve received a spoliation letter, it’s crucial to take it seriously. Here are the steps you should take:

1. Contact a lawyer immediately: If you don’t already have legal representation, now is the time to get it.
2. Follow the letter’s instructions: Preserve all evidence mentioned in the letter.
3. Implement a “litigation hold”: Suspend any routine document destruction or data overwriting processes.
4. Notify relevant parties: Inform employees or other individuals who might have access to the evidence about the preservation requirement.
5. Document your efforts: Keep records of your steps to comply with the letter.

Failing to comply with a spoliation letter can have serious legal consequences.

How Zanes Law Can Help With Letters of Spoliation

At Zanes Law, we’re committed to standing up for you throughout your personal injury case. Our experienced team will create letters of spoliation for your claim so that the defendant cannot hide or alter evidence without facing legal consequences.

Don’t let crucial evidence slip away. If you’ve been injured due to someone else’s negligence, contact Zanes Law today. We’ll fight to preserve the evidence you need and build a strong case on your behalf. Let us help you seek the justice and compensation you deserve.

Call or text 866-499-8989 or complete a
Free Case Evaluation form

Personal Injury Blog Posts:

Injury Lawyer Doug Zanes Interviewed For “Business Leader Spotlight”

Doug was recently interviewed by Randy Van Ittersum on the "Business Leader Spotlight Show." It was a great experience and gave him the opportunity to share important topics that are super

Need Personal Injury Legal Advice? Listen to Our NEW Podcast by Doug Zanes!

We are excited to announce that we have officially launched the Zanes Law Personal Injury Legal Tips podcast, featuring advice from Zanes Law owner and responsible attorney Doug Zanes. When

Should you hire an injury attorney? 5 Things You Need to Know

We know that when you’ve been injured in an accident, it can be difficult to take legal action quickly. After an accident, you might just want everything to be over and done with, so you

Can I Settle An Injury Claim On My Own?

Nobody expects to be in an accident—let alone get injured in an accident—but when it does happen, you may be asking yourself a lot of questions, including, “Can I settle an injury claim on my