Competency Issues Still Undecided In Teen Bus Slaying Due To Disabilities

The driver who is waiting to be tried in a case of second-degree murder after he struck and killed a 15-year-old student getting off a school bus Kayenta in 2017 is still waiting for officials to decide whether he is competent enough to be put on trial.

The Navajo Times reports that Peter Lee Charley was charged for his role in the death of McKenzie Tsosie after he allegedly hit her with his vehicle while she was getting off a school bus on the evening of October 31st of 2017.

Court records indicate that rather than stopping for the school bus that had its lights and signs engaged, Charley, who was traveling at a high rate of speed went around the bus, striking and killing Tsosie. Charley did not stop after hitting the teen.

The driver of the school bus and others witnessed the incident. The bus driver also happened to be McKenzie Tsosie’s father.

Arizona State Police Officer, Sgt. Bob Martin, who had just finished his shift, was also an eyewitness to the fatal crash. He pursued Charley and pulled him over approximately two miles from the scene. Also inside Charley’s vehicle was a female passenger.

Martin indicated that the car smelled strongly of alcohol and that Charley’s zipper was undone and his genitals were exposed. A Breathalyzer test at the scene determined that Charley had a blood alcohol level of 0.15 at the time – nearly twice the legal limit of 0.08.

Three psychologists were asked by the court to determine whether Charley, who is deaf, was competent to stand trial for the charges against him. All three determined that he was not competent, but all were also reluctant to issue the conclusion due to a lack of information about how Charley was able to deal with his disabilities throughout his life and before the accident.

While the battle continues based on whether Charley can perform daily tasks, learn and retain information, prosecutors are requesting the judge determine Charley’s fitness for trial in the case.

Related Frequently Asked Questions

  • 04 Mar 2019
    What if Both Drivers Are Partially at Fault in a Car Accident?
    Arizona Statute § 12-2505 dictates that each party can likely still recover compensation even if both drivers are partially at fault in a car accident. This is because Arizona personal injury law is based on the idea of pure comparative negligence (as opposed to pure contributory negligence or proportional c
  • 29 Oct 2019
    What Happens If You Get In An Accident With A Drunk Driver?
    When you get in an accident with a drunk driver, the law enforcement officer who responds to the accident scene will evaluate the accident and, if they believe that the drunk driver’s intoxication caused the accident, the police officer will call on Arizona’s implied consent laws to test the driver’s bl

Related Blog Posts

  • 08 Mar 2016
    Sinkhole in Gilbert
    Sinkhole in Gilbert It may have looked like a scene from an apocalypse movie as construction crews in Gilbert worked to determine what caused the road to collapse and form a hole that swallowed a pick-up truck last Monday night. (more…)
  • 20 Sep 2014
    Repercussions of Car Accidents can be Both Physically and Mentally Damaging
    It seems surreal at first, like watching a movie in slow motion. You almost can’t believe how fast the car is coming…you keep thinking he’ll slow down…he has to slow down…but he doesn’t. The car keeps coming and there is nowhere to go. You are sandwiched between other cars – a suburban truck fi

Get Your Free Case Evaluation

If you or a loved one has suffered an injury, or worse... we are here to help.
Please don't hesitate to reach out.

Zanes Law Logo
Click to call

Get Your Free Case Evaluation

By submitting this form I agree to the Terms of Use