Limits Raised On The Amount Of Money At-Fault Drivers Have To Pay

Last week, the Arizona Court of Appeals ruled that the state of Arizona cannot limit the amount of money at-fault drivers have to pay to accident victims or their surviving family members. reports that the panel of judges overturned the 2006 law that required those who were convicted of a traffic offense in which someone was either injured or killed to pay restitution, but limited the maximum amount that could be levied to just $10,000. In 2018, that amount was raised and capped to $100,000.

Judge Lawrence Winthrop, who was one of three judges on the Court of Appeals panel said in his opinion that the law goes against the Victim’s Bill of Rights which was added as an Arizona Constitutional Amendment in 1990 and that any limit on the dollar amount that would be set would be considered unconstitutional.

This latest decision comes after a case in which an at-fault driver, Vivek Patel, was convicted of failing to yield when making a left turn. The crash that Patel caused resulted in the serious injury of another person. The decision in the Patel case triggered two additional laws; one which makes it a criminal offense for breaking the traffic law that caused the accident, and a Victim’s Bill of Rights case. 

In the latter case, the Phoenix City Prosecutor sought damages of more than $61,000, which the municipal court judge awarded to the victim, who was not identified.  That decision was later overturned by Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Patricia Starr, who imposed the $10,000 cap on the monies awarded to the victim based on the wording on the Victim’s Rights Law which said that victims were entitled to “prompt” compensation in damages rather than “full compensation.”

Judge Winthrop disagreed with Judge Starr’s previous ruling, said that while the word “restitution” is not defined in the Constitutional law, the definition of compensation in the dictionary does define the word as restoring the victim to a state that they were in prior to the event.  

Judge Winthrop concluded in his remarks that when considering the amount of compensation sought by and awarded to victims should take into consideration the crime as well as the economic hardship that the event caused in the victim’s life.

Related Frequently Asked Questions

  • 29 Oct 2019
    What Happens If You Get In An Accident With A Drunk Driver?
    When you get in an accident with a drunk driver, the law enforcement officer who responds to the accident scene will evaluate the accident and, if they believe that the drunk driver’s intoxication caused the accident, the police officer will call on Arizona’s implied consent laws to test the driver’s bl
  • 02 Aug 2019
    Who Determines The Value Of My Car After A Car Accident In Phoenix, AZ?
    After a car accident, the insurance company will attempt to assign a value to your automobile. They will send an adjuster out, and the adjuster will likely perform a physical inspection of your car. They will also look at the year, make, model, and mileage to determine the market value of the car, from which

Related Blog Posts

  • 15 Jul 2019
    Woman Pierces Eye With Metal Drinking Straw In Accident, Dies
    Public concern over the sheer volume of plastic in our oceans and environment has led to a grassroots movement where people give up plastic straws. In their place, consumers are opting to use metal straws instead that can be reused indefinitely. Fox 10 in Phoenix recently reported that something as simple
  • 30 Jan 2015
    Practice the Phoenix Super Bowl Motto: Fans Don’t Let Fans Drive Drunk
    With less than a week left until Super Bowl XLIX, it’s time to make sure your plan for the weekend will ensure a fun and safe time, without getting a DUI.  With such a large occasion happening right here in Phoenix, Arizona, our home state is going to be filled with drivers who aren’t familia

Get Your Free Case Evaluation

If you or a loved one has suffered an injury, or worse... we are here to help.
Please don't hesitate to reach out.

Zanes Law Logo
Click to call

Get Your Free Case Evaluation

By submitting this form I agree to the Terms of Use